The University of Pennsylvania Law Review study published last year claimed to be the “first-ever independent analysis of in absentia removal orders” based on EOIR data from 2008 to 2018.
Authored by Ingrid Eagly, a professor of law at the UCLA School of Law, and Steven Shafer, the managing attorney for the Esperanza Immigrant Rights Project, the study found that “88% of all immigrants in immigration court with completed or pending removal cases over the past eleven years attended all of their court hearings.”
The authors said: “If we limit our analysis to only nondetained cases, we still find a high compliance rate: 83% of all respondents in completed or pending removal cases attended all of their hearings since 2008. Moreover, we reveal that 15% of those who were ordered deported in absentia since 2008 successfully reopened their cases and had their in absentia orders rescinded.”
Furthermore, the analysis revealed that people who applied for protection from removal or deportation had an even higher rate of attendance.
“Individuals who filed claims for relief (such as asylum or cancellation of removal) are very unlikely to miss court: 95% attended all of their court hearings over the eleven years of our study in pending and completed nondetained cases,” the study found.
That trend for people seeking asylum continued into FY 2019, according to a TRAC analysis, which found that nearly 99% of nondetained asylum seekers attended all of their court hearings.
Someone’s knockin’ at the door Somebody’s ringin’ the bell Someone’s knockin’ at the door Somebody’s ringin’ the bell Do me a favor Open the door and let ’em in
Besides processing them and returning them home, what do you suggest?
I wonder what the human migration might look like if, let’s say, the San Andres Fault lets go. Or, the Yosemite Caldara* goes off.
In the face of disasters, man-made and natural, humans will migrate. The worse the situation, the greater the migration. It’s been going on for humans since we crawled out of Africa. Thinking you can control it is hubris.
Thing is, if Biden hadn’t shot his mouth off during the debates giving an open invite to illegal immigrants to cross the border, continue to do so on National TV and then reverse President Trump’s policies on the border, we wouldn’t have a crises. Making the incompetent VIce President, Que Mala Eres, the border ‘Czar’ was a joke and an empty gesture. Both Biden and His VP are openly lying about mounted border agents ‘whipping’ Haitians illegally crossing the border. The photographer who took those pictures flat out said, that no whipping took place and no one was struck by the reins.
Fox and the RWNJs said Biden had open border policies ever since he ran for office, and kept up the fiction right up until today. Idiots gobble it up and believe it.
Lisa, did you take that sign with you when you were storming the Capitol as a domestic terrorist? Your accompanying insurrectionists haven’t faced any real consequences. Isn’t that what you have been demanding for 15 years? No consequences for YOUR actions.
I don’t understand. Does Ms. Benson read the news? The Biden administration just just deported 14,000 Haitians by flying them back to Haiti. How is that catch and release?
From anything I read in the news, the Biden administration is following the same plan as the Trump administration with the exception of unaccompanied minors, using the pandemic rules of not allowing people in. They do have to allow people who have asylum claims as that is the law. Other than that they’re send people back.
The usual idiots will claim something like – democrats are importing voters. They have nothing to back that up with, it’s just trolling or fantasy.
What this ignores is that the vast majority of immigrants released awaiting a hearing show up. It’s not necessary—and would be incredibly counter-productive—to confine them.
More right wing nonsense. The Biden Admin has been setting records with fast paced deportations during the last 8 months using the same unconstitutional justification that the prior administration used.
Trespassers will also not be tested for COVID, infectious diseases, criminal records, terrorist history or a desire to harm or kill honest LAW ABIDING people.
Thanks Biden! You are such an (anti)American hero!
The reports I’ve been seeing are that it’s plane tickets… to Haiti, even for many individuals who didn’t come directly from there. (There aren’t many buses that run between the US and Haiti.)
They aren’t trespassers, Loco-Weed Lisa. They’re Refugees.
BIG difference. Refugees have a right to cross the border, and establish residency before they apply for refugee status, so they’re in a safe place as they wait.
It’s those that try to cast them as the villains, and try to claim they’re a danger to America, that are the real Evil Bastards.
tamrich59 over 2 years ago
Biden is ruining our country at warp speed!!
jhayesd31 over 2 years ago
Why hasn’t Biden been able to solve deep rooted systemic and existential problems that have been haunting America for years….. in the First 247 days?
guyjen2004 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Don’t worry, folks…they’ll all show up for their hearings. /s
Iseau over 2 years ago
That sign will work just fine and it’s a lot cheaper than a wall. And a free bus ride to boot. Why didn’t someone think of that before. Good job Joe.
IndyW over 2 years ago
Welcome to the Un-united States of America. Thanks Joe Biden.
Teto85 Premium Member over 2 years ago
The most dangerous immigrants arrived in 1492
charliekane over 2 years ago
Just sayin’, from:
https://www.factcheck.org/2021/04/factchecking-claims-about-asylum-grants-and-immigration-court-attendance/
The University of Pennsylvania Law Review study published last year claimed to be the “first-ever independent analysis of in absentia removal orders” based on EOIR data from 2008 to 2018.
Authored by Ingrid Eagly, a professor of law at the UCLA School of Law, and Steven Shafer, the managing attorney for the Esperanza Immigrant Rights Project, the study found that “88% of all immigrants in immigration court with completed or pending removal cases over the past eleven years attended all of their court hearings.”
The authors said: “If we limit our analysis to only nondetained cases, we still find a high compliance rate: 83% of all respondents in completed or pending removal cases attended all of their hearings since 2008. Moreover, we reveal that 15% of those who were ordered deported in absentia since 2008 successfully reopened their cases and had their in absentia orders rescinded.”
Furthermore, the analysis revealed that people who applied for protection from removal or deportation had an even higher rate of attendance.
“Individuals who filed claims for relief (such as asylum or cancellation of removal) are very unlikely to miss court: 95% attended all of their court hearings over the eleven years of our study in pending and completed nondetained cases,” the study found.
That trend for people seeking asylum continued into FY 2019, according to a TRAC analysis, which found that nearly 99% of nondetained asylum seekers attended all of their court hearings.
knutdl over 2 years ago
Someone’s knockin’ at the door Somebody’s ringin’ the bell Someone’s knockin’ at the door Somebody’s ringin’ the bell Do me a favor Open the door and let ’em in
The Love of Money is . . . over 2 years ago
Something sounds fishy about Lisa’s “catch and release” cartoon . . .hook, line and ‘stinker’.
rs0204 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Besides processing them and returning them home, what do you suggest?
I wonder what the human migration might look like if, let’s say, the San Andres Fault lets go. Or, the Yosemite Caldara* goes off.
In the face of disasters, man-made and natural, humans will migrate. The worse the situation, the greater the migration. It’s been going on for humans since we crawled out of Africa. Thinking you can control it is hubris.
*https://www.livescience.com/20714-yellowstone-supervolcano-eruption.html
Kracklin Rosie - “Tolo Dan Nan Galad” Premium Member over 2 years ago
Thing is, if Biden hadn’t shot his mouth off during the debates giving an open invite to illegal immigrants to cross the border, continue to do so on National TV and then reverse President Trump’s policies on the border, we wouldn’t have a crises. Making the incompetent VIce President, Que Mala Eres, the border ‘Czar’ was a joke and an empty gesture. Both Biden and His VP are openly lying about mounted border agents ‘whipping’ Haitians illegally crossing the border. The photographer who took those pictures flat out said, that no whipping took place and no one was struck by the reins.
Patjade over 2 years ago
^^ He didn’t, but that’s what Fox kept saying he did for the idiots to repeat.
https://www.cato.org/commentary/bidens-closed-door-immigration-policies-are-not-open-borders
https://apnews.com/article/joe-biden-mexico-elections-central-america-latin-america-4ef027b9e95a4ef63da4cab80d68b177
https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/jul/28/tweets/us-mexico-border-not-wide-open-most-people-trying-/
https://www.forbes.com/sites/joewalsh/2021/03/14/no-the-us-mexico-border-isnt-open-despite-surge-in-migrants/
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/20/us/politics/fact-check-immigration-border.html
Fox and the RWNJs said Biden had open border policies ever since he ran for office, and kept up the fiction right up until today. Idiots gobble it up and believe it.
Vidrinath Premium Member over 2 years ago
Lisa, did you take that sign with you when you were storming the Capitol as a domestic terrorist? Your accompanying insurrectionists haven’t faced any real consequences. Isn’t that what you have been demanding for 15 years? No consequences for YOUR actions.
Why do hate America?
ferddo over 2 years ago
If Trump’s wall was so effective, how can illegals get in?
DrDon1 over 2 years ago
Benson isn’t interested in a meaningful solution to any issue or problem!
The Real M38 over 2 years ago
Wow. The righty GQP are out in force today. Yikes!
RAGs over 2 years ago
Hey Lisa, try something new for a change, such as Truth.
dnie1951 over 2 years ago
Only way for Dem$ to get more “voter$”…………………
ChristopherBurns over 2 years ago
I don’t understand. Does Ms. Benson read the news? The Biden administration just just deported 14,000 Haitians by flying them back to Haiti. How is that catch and release?
From anything I read in the news, the Biden administration is following the same plan as the Trump administration with the exception of unaccompanied minors, using the pandemic rules of not allowing people in. They do have to allow people who have asylum claims as that is the law. Other than that they’re send people back.
The usual idiots will claim something like – democrats are importing voters. They have nothing to back that up with, it’s just trolling or fantasy.
Rich Douglas over 2 years ago
What this ignores is that the vast majority of immigrants released awaiting a hearing show up. It’s not necessary—and would be incredibly counter-productive—to confine them.
Durak Premium Member over 2 years ago
You don’t like the immigration policy demand your Republican Congressman do something about it.
ndblackirish97 over 2 years ago
More right wing nonsense. The Biden Admin has been setting records with fast paced deportations during the last 8 months using the same unconstitutional justification that the prior administration used.
suv2000 over 2 years ago
What a load of bull I watch CNN MSNBC the view and they had nothing on the story like this
Bill.Franklin over 2 years ago
Trespassers will also not be tested for COVID, infectious diseases, criminal records, terrorist history or a desire to harm or kill honest LAW ABIDING people.
Thanks Biden! You are such an (anti)American hero!
gammaguy over 2 years ago
“Bus ticket included”
The reports I’ve been seeing are that it’s plane tickets… to Haiti, even for many individuals who didn’t come directly from there. (There aren’t many buses that run between the US and Haiti.)
359mxn over 2 years ago
The horror, the horror. Since when?
Suede Civilian over 2 years ago
They aren’t trespassers, Loco-Weed Lisa. They’re Refugees.
BIG difference. Refugees have a right to cross the border, and establish residency before they apply for refugee status, so they’re in a safe place as they wait.
It’s those that try to cast them as the villains, and try to claim they’re a danger to America, that are the real Evil Bastards.
Aubrey Dacus over 2 years ago
I am in total agreement, as long as the Bus rides end in L.A. or N.Y. City. Send them where they are wanted.
cbgoldeneagle2 over 2 years ago
https://www.theepochtimes.com/mkt_breakingnews/dhs-secretary-as-many-as-12000-illegal-haitian-immigrants-released-into-the-us-in-recent-days_4015864.html/
cbgoldeneagle2 over 2 years ago
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/mayorkas-says-as-many-as-12k-out-of-17k-migrants-have-been-released-into-u-s-and-it-could-be-higher-as-dhs
SarvopamaDasa over 2 years ago
It’s not a pandemic, it’s an IQ test.