After WW2 in 1949, we enacted the Fairness Doctrine because we saw how lies unchecked had encouraged the rise of fascism in Europe. “Honest, equitable and balanced,” would that be a step too far, to protect free speech in America?
“The fairness doctrine of the United States Federal Communications Commission (FCC), introduced in 1949, was a policy that required the holders of broadcast licenses to both present controversial issues of public importance and to do so in a manner that was honest, equitable, and balanced.” WIKI
There’s no threat to freedom of speech. Trump, people who support him, conspiracy theorists, Q-anon, Militia Men, Proud Boys, Bugaloo, etc. are all learning that you’re responsible for what you say and what happens after you say it.
People are still allowed to express themselves responsibly.
Not if “free speech” involves inciting crowds of unhinged supporters into storming and defacing government buildings, using assault weapons to terrorize citizens, and carrying around zip ties with the aim of holding our lawmakers hostage.
The words “cancel culture” have no meaning. If they did everything that Trump has done would fall under that term, from trying to eliminate everything his predecessor accomplished to turning all Democratic governors and mayors into enemies to eliminating science as an approach to solving pandemic and climate issues. I could probably go on about things he’s tried to cancel, but it is exhausting.
So why do republicans lie all the time and hide the truth?
Benedict Arnold Trump was punished for inciting a riot where they intended to kill Pence and Pelosi. A twitter ban is a slap on the wrist, Trump should be in prison.
Talk about cancel culture, the insanely moronic Republicans still don’t believe the majority of the American public voted out their orange lying racist dictator Trump and they want to fight everyone now.
This isn’t just about the Trump ban! Who really cares about Trump being banned? Amazon flexed it’s monopoly to prevent Parler from coming back. Thousands upon thousands of people got banned from Twitter following the riot. Banned, not suspended. I suspect a fair portion did not advocate violence.
Mr. Ramirez, I have defended you when you cite facts, do that for us now please, give us the facts as to what particular words are being canceled, so that we too can make informed decisions. thank you.
I find it humorous, although quite understandable, that Ramirez would choose a Nazi airship to represent America. What next Ramirez, Tokyo Rose as lady liberty?
Free.. but irresponsible speech, is the problem. Pushing the boundaries with “shock” draws the ratings which draws the advertising dollars.. which demands more shock to where we are today.
Let me exercise my right to free speech. Micheal, you’re an idiot. with freedom comes responsibility, a fact that the tRumplicans and their ilk seem to ignore.
Yes, I know the following does not specifically address the right wing invention of “cancel culture,” but many comments are directed toward Trump’s fomenting rebellion.
From Wikipedia:
“Shouting fire in a crowded theater” is a popular analogy for speech or actions made for the principal purpose of creating panic. The phrase is a paraphrasing of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.‘s opinion in the United States Supreme Court case Schenck v. United States in 1919, which held that the defendant’s speech in opposition to the draft during World War I was not protected free speech under the First Amendment of the United States Constitution. The case was later partially overturned by Brandenburg v. Ohio in 1969, which limited the scope of banned speech to that which would be directed to and likely to incite imminent lawless action (e.g. a riot).
The paraphrasing differs from Holmes’s original wording in that it typically does not include the word falsely, while also adding the word “crowded” to describe the theatre. The original wording used in Holmes’s opinion (“falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic”) highlights that speech that is dangerous and false is not protected, as opposed to speech that is dangerous but also true.
And there you have it. Trump has falsely been claiming that he lost because of fraud. And his invitations to protest did incite lawless action.
There is every legal reason, therefore to ban Trump from exercising his power to incite riot. Along with many others.
Mr. Ramirez has given us his latest serving of freedom of speech. Oddly enough, today, he does this by lying about threats to freedom of speech. Confusion reigns in the Ramirez Studio.
Cancel culture is a pain in the ass. It makes it’s practitioners look petty and close minded.
But. The right has some nerve calling it out. The music industry has a verb “dixiechicked” meaning your career gets stomped on when you take an unpopular political stand. We could also talk about McCarthyism which canceled many careers in the 50’s.
Yes, if cancel culture means eradicating the hateful white supremacist, racist, anti-Semitic and misogynist element from our society then it deserves to go down in flames. As far as free speech goes, I don’t hear of the government restricting anyones voice. Do you?
The biggest threat to free speech is the government. Isn’t the part of government that enforces the laws still controlled by Donald Trump? Ramirez arguing against himself and his masters again.
Trump threatened to censor news media channels and have the FCC pull their licenses, but Trumpers do not perceive that as threatening freedom of speech…
Cancel culture, the Totalitarian approved way to punish anyone personally, professionally, and financially if they are found out to support the wrong candidate, cause, or agenda. Fear and intimidation can be a powerful motivator to get the submission desired in Authoritarian regimes. Xiden’s deep thinkers are already talking about “deprogramming” people, which is a good euphemism for re-education camps.
Right, Ramirez. American terrorists attack the Capitol of the United States, but the fact that the traitor who incited them to treason and violence faced consequences for his words and actions is the worst thing ever!
This is the thing Republicans have abused time and again. Freedom of speech has it’s limits. Freedom of speech was never intended to protect people from lying, inciting violence, and letting a bunch of murderous thugs overthrow our government.
Sadly, all too often it has been allowed to do so.
The biggest threats to America are a) lax gun laws; b) poor education levels; c) low wages; d) poor public health; e) politicians who lie, cheat and steal. The list is long, should you care to examine life in America Mr Ramirez. The ‘cancel culture’ is the least of your problems. People have been banning things for over one hundred years. In my old trade union days we had bans on dealing with merchants and companies who underpaid wages, or treated employees as second class. Unionists would refuse to unload ships from countries who treated their citizens cruelly and we would ban exports to the same. Nothing new and the world carried on.
Let’s see. No environment agreements, no Iran deal, no healthcare, no pandemic eradication plan. Thank the PARTY OF STUPID (Republicans) for canceling all things that could have given hope to America in the last four years.
The biggest threat might actually be the misuse of freedom of speech as made available by social media. Who knew that PAYING for news and HIRING EDITORS with a trained conscience to run the news desk could be so important?
Ramirez represents America as the Hindenburg, a zeppelin that was at times used to drop Adolf Hitler’s fascist propaganda…. swastikas emblazoned on its tail. After four long years with the Mussolini impersonator as president, with the Fox News, Breitbart and National Review adding a pinch of right wing spin to every story, Ramirez is so off balance, he can’t tell who he stands with….. seems he’s with Trump’s fascist “Proud Boys” ….
“Although designed and built for commercial transatlantic passenger, air freight, and mail service, at the behest of the Reich Ministry for Public Enlightenment and Propaganda (Reichsministerium für Volksaufklärung und Propaganda or Propagandaministerium), Hindenburg was first pressed into use by the Air Ministry (its DLZ co-operator) as a vehicle for the delivery of Nazi propaganda.” WIKI
It sounds like a really good solution to set up a committee of some sort to preview news and only allow the broadcast of the true, factually based information that is needed to form opinions. Then go ahead and give opinions, but clearly label them as opinions.But who keeps an eye on the committee to be sure it doesn’t slowly creep in one direction or the other? It might be safer to have Faux and Limbaugh clearly and knowingly lying through their teeth than to have something that we are supposed to be able to trust that could be corrupted.
Say What Now‽ Premium Member over 3 years ago
Ramirez misses the Rump’s lies and hateful tweets.
By the way Ramirez, those companies have every right to enforce their terms of use.
braindead Premium Member over 3 years ago
I guess beating a cop to death is just another form of free expression.
You know, like money being speech and all.
feverjr Premium Member over 3 years ago
After WW2 in 1949, we enacted the Fairness Doctrine because we saw how lies unchecked had encouraged the rise of fascism in Europe. “Honest, equitable and balanced,” would that be a step too far, to protect free speech in America?
“The fairness doctrine of the United States Federal Communications Commission (FCC), introduced in 1949, was a policy that required the holders of broadcast licenses to both present controversial issues of public importance and to do so in a manner that was honest, equitable, and balanced.” WIKI
baroden Premium Member over 3 years ago
There’s no threat to freedom of speech. Trump, people who support him, conspiracy theorists, Q-anon, Militia Men, Proud Boys, Bugaloo, etc. are all learning that you’re responsible for what you say and what happens after you say it.
People are still allowed to express themselves responsibly.
Pogostiks Premium Member over 3 years ago
He’s right. The electorate spoke and now all the Republicans are trying to pretend the majority didn’t vote Biden!
Zev over 3 years ago
Not if “free speech” involves inciting crowds of unhinged supporters into storming and defacing government buildings, using assault weapons to terrorize citizens, and carrying around zip ties with the aim of holding our lawmakers hostage.
BubbleTape Premium Member over 3 years ago
And he’s back. More like yelling fire in a crowded theater – when there is no fire.
Kurtass Premium Member over 3 years ago
Another trumpcultist that doesn’t under the First Amendment. He also doesn’t understand there are consequences to free speech.
Zebrastripes over 3 years ago
The biggest threat to America is speech inciting hate, VIOLENCE, lying to WE THE PEOPLE, and singling out people for who they are!
Taste the air Premium Member over 3 years ago
The words “cancel culture” have no meaning. If they did everything that Trump has done would fall under that term, from trying to eliminate everything his predecessor accomplished to turning all Democratic governors and mayors into enemies to eliminating science as an approach to solving pandemic and climate issues. I could probably go on about things he’s tried to cancel, but it is exhausting.
davidthoms1 over 3 years ago
Screaming fire in a crowded theater is not free speech! Neither is screaming “Stop the Steal” to gullible but well armed morons.
Radish the wordsmith over 3 years ago
So why do republicans lie all the time and hide the truth?
Benedict Arnold Trump was punished for inciting a riot where they intended to kill Pence and Pelosi. A twitter ban is a slap on the wrist, Trump should be in prison.
Radish the wordsmith over 3 years ago
Talk about cancel culture, the insanely moronic Republicans still don’t believe the majority of the American public voted out their orange lying racist dictator Trump and they want to fight everyone now.
NeedaChuckle Premium Member over 3 years ago
Of course this does NOT apply to BAKERY shops!! Right?
DonnyTwoScoops over 3 years ago
I would say the biggest threat is the radical right wing extremist Republican terrorists who just attacked our Capitol. But you go on Ramirez.
Denver Reader Premium Member over 3 years ago
This isn’t just about the Trump ban! Who really cares about Trump being banned? Amazon flexed it’s monopoly to prevent Parler from coming back. Thousands upon thousands of people got banned from Twitter following the riot. Banned, not suspended. I suspect a fair portion did not advocate violence.
codak over 3 years ago
facebook, through Cambridge analytica data mining and twitter made this man president . . I guess they can play the moralists now
walfishj over 3 years ago
Is that right wing or left wing cancel culture?
Tralfaz Premium Member over 3 years ago
Mr. Ramirez, I have defended you when you cite facts, do that for us now please, give us the facts as to what particular words are being canceled, so that we too can make informed decisions. thank you.
librarylady59 over 3 years ago
The explosion occurred in the Capitol, called for by trump and sycophants, carried out by his violent groupies.
Daltongang Premium Member over 3 years ago
I find it humorous, although quite understandable, that Ramirez would choose a Nazi airship to represent America. What next Ramirez, Tokyo Rose as lady liberty?
Alberta Oil Premium Member over 3 years ago
Free.. but irresponsible speech, is the problem. Pushing the boundaries with “shock” draws the ratings which draws the advertising dollars.. which demands more shock to where we are today.
rmfrye Premium Member over 3 years ago
Let me exercise my right to free speech. Micheal, you’re an idiot. with freedom comes responsibility, a fact that the tRumplicans and their ilk seem to ignore.
Patjade over 3 years ago
I guess when they can’t defend their own, they invent some conspiracy theory to deflect to.
Baslim the Beggar Premium Member over 3 years ago
Yes, I know the following does not specifically address the right wing invention of “cancel culture,” but many comments are directed toward Trump’s fomenting rebellion.
From Wikipedia:
“Shouting fire in a crowded theater” is a popular analogy for speech or actions made for the principal purpose of creating panic. The phrase is a paraphrasing of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.‘s opinion in the United States Supreme Court case Schenck v. United States in 1919, which held that the defendant’s speech in opposition to the draft during World War I was not protected free speech under the First Amendment of the United States Constitution. The case was later partially overturned by Brandenburg v. Ohio in 1969, which limited the scope of banned speech to that which would be directed to and likely to incite imminent lawless action (e.g. a riot).
The paraphrasing differs from Holmes’s original wording in that it typically does not include the word falsely, while also adding the word “crowded” to describe the theatre. The original wording used in Holmes’s opinion (“falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic”) highlights that speech that is dangerous and false is not protected, as opposed to speech that is dangerous but also true.
And there you have it. Trump has falsely been claiming that he lost because of fraud. And his invitations to protest did incite lawless action.
There is every legal reason, therefore to ban Trump from exercising his power to incite riot. Along with many others.
waltkamp over 3 years ago
Cancel Culture: private enterprise doing as it damn well pleases just like the GOP insists (at least where pollution is concerned).
6.6TA over 3 years ago
Mr. Ramirez has given us his latest serving of freedom of speech. Oddly enough, today, he does this by lying about threats to freedom of speech. Confusion reigns in the Ramirez Studio.
evanmarhews over 3 years ago
does Ramirez want to yell fire in a packed theater or bomb ! in a crowd ? free speech!!
ChristopherBurns over 3 years ago
Cancel culture is a pain in the ass. It makes it’s practitioners look petty and close minded.
But. The right has some nerve calling it out. The music industry has a verb “dixiechicked” meaning your career gets stomped on when you take an unpopular political stand. We could also talk about McCarthyism which canceled many careers in the 50’s.
The left did not invent cancel culture.
ibrooklyn over 3 years ago
Yes, if cancel culture means eradicating the hateful white supremacist, racist, anti-Semitic and misogynist element from our society then it deserves to go down in flames. As far as free speech goes, I don’t hear of the government restricting anyones voice. Do you?
ThomasBonsell over 3 years ago
The biggest threat to free speech is the government. Isn’t the part of government that enforces the laws still controlled by Donald Trump? Ramirez arguing against himself and his masters again.
ncorgbl over 3 years ago
The “cancel culture” took place when statues and monuments to the enemies of the U.S. were erected.
ferddo over 3 years ago
Trump threatened to censor news media channels and have the FCC pull their licenses, but Trumpers do not perceive that as threatening freedom of speech…
Another Take over 3 years ago
If “Cancel Culture” had any real power, we wouldn’t have stupid Ramirez cartoons to read.
Ivan Araque over 3 years ago
Totally agree, provided that man is CONVICTED for this ACT OF TREASON. Then we’ll deal with Facebook or whatever -
Alphadog over 3 years ago
Cancel culture, the Totalitarian approved way to punish anyone personally, professionally, and financially if they are found out to support the wrong candidate, cause, or agenda. Fear and intimidation can be a powerful motivator to get the submission desired in Authoritarian regimes. Xiden’s deep thinkers are already talking about “deprogramming” people, which is a good euphemism for re-education camps.
Daeder over 3 years ago
Right, Ramirez. American terrorists attack the Capitol of the United States, but the fact that the traitor who incited them to treason and violence faced consequences for his words and actions is the worst thing ever!
Eff you and the rest of the traitors.
T Smith over 3 years ago
A bigger threat to America is unapologetic propagandists like you.
GiantShetlandPony over 3 years ago
This is the thing Republicans have abused time and again. Freedom of speech has it’s limits. Freedom of speech was never intended to protect people from lying, inciting violence, and letting a bunch of murderous thugs overthrow our government.
Sadly, all too often it has been allowed to do so.
grumpypophobart over 3 years ago
The biggest threats to America are a) lax gun laws; b) poor education levels; c) low wages; d) poor public health; e) politicians who lie, cheat and steal. The list is long, should you care to examine life in America Mr Ramirez. The ‘cancel culture’ is the least of your problems. People have been banning things for over one hundred years. In my old trade union days we had bans on dealing with merchants and companies who underpaid wages, or treated employees as second class. Unionists would refuse to unload ships from countries who treated their citizens cruelly and we would ban exports to the same. Nothing new and the world carried on.
kentmarx36 over 3 years ago
Let’s see. No environment agreements, no Iran deal, no healthcare, no pandemic eradication plan. Thank the PARTY OF STUPID (Republicans) for canceling all things that could have given hope to America in the last four years.
Concretionist over 3 years ago
The biggest threat might actually be the misuse of freedom of speech as made available by social media. Who knew that PAYING for news and HIRING EDITORS with a trained conscience to run the news desk could be so important?
Julian Himber over 3 years ago
That’s why you are allowed to lie daily in newspaper across the USA.
nappingbat over 3 years ago
“Cancel culture” is in reality a free market being free.
Radish the wordsmith over 3 years ago
Fake News has dropped 73% since liar Trump the seditious was banned from Twitter.
Radish the wordsmith over 3 years ago
It wasn’t the left wing who banned Trump from Twitter it was a capitalist corporation trying to follow family values.
lonecat over 3 years ago
I’m a big believer in the free marketplace of ideas. Calling for people to be hanged is not an idea.
BE THIS GUY over 3 years ago
Yup, that’s what’s destroying America. It’s the cancel culture’s fault that the FBI is worried about an insider attack at the inauguration.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/military-inauguration-extremist-threat/2021/01/17/ed8885ba-593a-11eb-aaad-93988621dd28_story.html
feverjr Premium Member over 3 years ago
Ramirez represents America as the Hindenburg, a zeppelin that was at times used to drop Adolf Hitler’s fascist propaganda…. swastikas emblazoned on its tail. After four long years with the Mussolini impersonator as president, with the Fox News, Breitbart and National Review adding a pinch of right wing spin to every story, Ramirez is so off balance, he can’t tell who he stands with….. seems he’s with Trump’s fascist “Proud Boys” ….
“Although designed and built for commercial transatlantic passenger, air freight, and mail service, at the behest of the Reich Ministry for Public Enlightenment and Propaganda (Reichsministerium für Volksaufklärung und Propaganda or Propagandaministerium), Hindenburg was first pressed into use by the Air Ministry (its DLZ co-operator) as a vehicle for the delivery of Nazi propaganda.” WIKI
Diane Lee Premium Member over 3 years ago