Let’s see, West Virginia has a population of about 1.8 million. Just under 300,000 voted for Manchin in 2018. There are under 12,000 (2020) coal miners in the state. So, no, Manchin’s “base” in no way are coal miners.
Non compos mentis — Of course, the mine workers will demand that Manchin act as their Senator. It’s the basis of our democracy. This is nothing other than the old tuquoque and diversion worthy of a Drumpfster.
Coal is environmentally devastating and bad for health. The number of people employed by the industry has been decreasing steadily for years. Its economic impact is declining. I think conservatives cling to it out of some warped contrarian nostalgia.
This is like saying that workers on assembly lines are the same people as the owners of the car company. I disagree with Payne a lot, but I credited him with understanding the difference. My mistake.
Mr. Manchin, here’s something to chew on: If we keep funding the military at $750 Billion per year (and we will, probably adding a “cost-of-dying” factor each year), we will end up spending 7 1/2 TRILLION dollars over the space of ten years. And I don’t need the OMB to guaran-damn-tee you that it won’t pay for itself.
Actually Manchin is likely the only Democrat who still can be elected in WV. Like Obama said “they (working class whites in depressed areas) cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them or anti-immigrant sentiment” and that is how they vote, not in their economic interest. The average WV miner likely believes-if you can’t feed them, don’t breed them.
Wrong. Strawmen do not shovel coal, they just push the lie.
“In November, the Country Roads PAC received corporate contributions ranging from $2,500 to $5,000. Donors included financial giants such as American Express and Goldman Sachs, aerospace and defense leader Lockheed Martin, health insurance companies UnitedHealth Group and Blue Cross Blue Shield, and natural gas company CNX Resources. The PAC raised over $110,000 in November.”CNBC news, not fake but backed with objective facts
Well, inter alia the Koch Industries, though that’s more oil than coal. But a couple of dozen other Large Money people. It’s not Sen. Sanders’ imagination. Who knows what or who has made Manchin a puppet, but he plainly has sawdust for brains.
Bernie is a silly man. He rails against fossil fuels and then gets on his jet to the next town to do more railing. If Biden is to survive, he needs to grow a pair and expunge the socialists out of his orbit. Doubtful that he is that intelligent at this point.
“A day after the West Virginia Democrat appeared to kill Build Back Better, America’s largest coal mining union put out a statement lauding the legislation’s provisions and pushing Manchin to take a do-over.”
“We urge Senator Manchin to revisit his opposition to this legislation and work with his colleagues to pass something that will help keep coal miners working, and have a meaningful impact on our members, their families and their communities.”
Heaven forbid he doesnt give the Far left a blank check to put us further in debt. Also heaven forbid you trolls actually read the bill and not just go what your press and reps tell you.
Concretionist over 2 years ago
You must be kidding.
Paynefully stupid. And that’s saying a lot.
Say What Now‽ Premium Member over 2 years ago
If Manchin cared a hoot about them, he would’ve passed the bill.
RAGs over 2 years ago
I read that coal miners are asking Manchin to dial back his opposition to “Build Back Better”
mr_sherman Premium Member over 2 years ago
I doubt the coal magnates dress like that.
Daeder over 2 years ago
Henry Payne thinks that the people who own coal mines are the ones doing the mining.
How dumb can he get? I keep thinking we’ve finally answered that question, but he just keeps going!
GOGOPOWERANGERS over 2 years ago
Really miners?
I’m trying to figure how you came to that conclusion and I can’t
sevaar777 over 2 years ago
Makes absolutely no sense at all. Please, HP, check yourself into rehab ASAP. The drug abuse/alcohol is really showing in your “work”.
braindead Premium Member over 2 years ago
Henry, your LIES are getting even stupider.
I didn’t think that could happen.
Havel over 2 years ago
Let’s see, West Virginia has a population of about 1.8 million. Just under 300,000 voted for Manchin in 2018. There are under 12,000 (2020) coal miners in the state. So, no, Manchin’s “base” in no way are coal miners.
1BlackLivesMatter Premium Member over 2 years ago
Great ‘toon! Sanders is a typical liberal. Let’s go, Brandon!
VegaAlopex over 2 years ago
Non compos mentis — Of course, the mine workers will demand that Manchin act as their Senator. It’s the basis of our democracy. This is nothing other than the old tuquoque and diversion worthy of a Drumpfster.
The Nodding Head over 2 years ago
Coal is environmentally devastating and bad for health. The number of people employed by the industry has been decreasing steadily for years. Its economic impact is declining. I think conservatives cling to it out of some warped contrarian nostalgia.
grange Premium Member over 2 years ago
Manchin IS the wealthy special interest.
Teto85 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Good to see that the supply chain situation is not affecting Payne’s ability to get his two bowls of stupid for breakfast every morning.
Jane b Lee over 2 years ago
Gen.Flashman over 2 years ago
There are about 12,000 coal miners in WV and about 40% (5,000) are UMW members and likely 75% of them voted for trump.
walfishj over 2 years ago
As so often happens, Payne lies.
Valiant1943 Premium Member over 2 years ago
True… but his family business paid for his boat and Masserrati.
rmfrye Premium Member over 2 years ago
Having trouble with the facts again Henry?
StackableContainers over 2 years ago
This is like saying that workers on assembly lines are the same people as the owners of the car company. I disagree with Payne a lot, but I credited him with understanding the difference. My mistake.
jader3rd over 2 years ago
The coal miners want Build Back Better. It’s the hedge funds that own the coal mines that don’t.
jack666 Premium Member over 2 years ago
This cartoon has twisted truth and logic beyond recognition.
I Play One On TV over 2 years ago
Mr. Manchin, here’s something to chew on: If we keep funding the military at $750 Billion per year (and we will, probably adding a “cost-of-dying” factor each year), we will end up spending 7 1/2 TRILLION dollars over the space of ten years. And I don’t need the OMB to guaran-damn-tee you that it won’t pay for itself.
Why doesn’t THAT matter to you?
Patjade over 2 years ago
Stupid Henry Payne still shows how stupid he is.
https://edition.cnn.com/2021/12/21/business/coal-miners-joe-manchin/index.html
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/manchin-united-mine-workers-build-back-better/
https://www.winknews.com/2021/12/22/largest-us-coal-miners-union-asks-manchin-to-support-build-back-better/
https://umwa.org/news-media/press/umwa-statement-on-build-back-better-legislation/
Gen.Flashman over 2 years ago
Actually Manchin is likely the only Democrat who still can be elected in WV. Like Obama said “they (working class whites in depressed areas) cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them or anti-immigrant sentiment” and that is how they vote, not in their economic interest. The average WV miner likely believes-if you can’t feed them, don’t breed them.
mikemck over 2 years ago
Swing and a miss.
syzygy47 over 2 years ago
Wrong. Strawmen do not shovel coal, they just push the lie.
“In November, the Country Roads PAC received corporate contributions ranging from $2,500 to $5,000. Donors included financial giants such as American Express and Goldman Sachs, aerospace and defense leader Lockheed Martin, health insurance companies UnitedHealth Group and Blue Cross Blue Shield, and natural gas company CNX Resources. The PAC raised over $110,000 in November.”CNBC news, not fake but backed with objective facts
Radish the wordsmith over 2 years ago
Payne lies again.
AndrewSihler over 2 years ago
Well, inter alia the Koch Industries, though that’s more oil than coal. But a couple of dozen other Large Money people. It’s not Sen. Sanders’ imagination. Who knows what or who has made Manchin a puppet, but he plainly has sawdust for brains.
Stat_man99 over 2 years ago
Yep.
Union Man over 2 years ago
Henry, do you think Manchin ever wore a pair of Carhartt’s? Actually, worked in a coal mine?
rwebs over 2 years ago
Bernie is a silly man. He rails against fossil fuels and then gets on his jet to the next town to do more railing. If Biden is to survive, he needs to grow a pair and expunge the socialists out of his orbit. Doubtful that he is that intelligent at this point.
calliarcale over 2 years ago
It’s not the coal miners who have made him their puppet. It’s the wealthy coal barons who employ them.
apfelzra Premium Member over 2 years ago
It’s the coal mine OWNERS and other fossil fuel interests, not the miners, who seem to be funding Manchin’s political activities.
Uncle Joe Premium Member over 2 years ago
“A day after the West Virginia Democrat appeared to kill Build Back Better, America’s largest coal mining union put out a statement lauding the legislation’s provisions and pushing Manchin to take a do-over.”
“We urge Senator Manchin to revisit his opposition to this legislation and work with his colleagues to pass something that will help keep coal miners working, and have a meaningful impact on our members, their families and their communities.”
https://www.cnn.com/2021/12/21/business/coal-miners-joe-manchin/index.html
washatkc Premium Member over 2 years ago
Heaven forbid he doesnt give the Far left a blank check to put us further in debt. Also heaven forbid you trolls actually read the bill and not just go what your press and reps tell you.