Not as illogical as it sounds. If you go back a thousand years or so, “fish” meant almost anything that mostly lived in water. That would have included muskrats if they’d been known.
And it’s actually no worse a way of looking at things than the current one, because according to at least one notable biologist, Stephen Jay Gould, there’s no such thing as a fish (see, e.g., the BBC QI episode “H for Hoax”). Lots of “fish” are more closely related to land animals than to each other. The modern definition basically boils down to the old one, with caveats of “but not those!”
But on St. Patrick’s Day, which is a Friday this year, Catholics can have their corned beef. Some Pope gave Catholics a pass on No Meat Fridays for good ol’ St. Pat.
Templo S.U.D. about 1 year ago
the Catholics in medieval times also considered beaver as fish
oldpine52 about 1 year ago
Is that Suzie or Sam that she stewed?
Blissfulvalley Premium Member about 1 year ago
What?! I had to look this up. It is in fact true.
https://www.detroitcatholic.com/news/the-history-of-detroit-catholics-muskrat-eating-tradition-and-yes-its-still-a-thing
fredd13 about 1 year ago
Not as illogical as it sounds. If you go back a thousand years or so, “fish” meant almost anything that mostly lived in water. That would have included muskrats if they’d been known.
And it’s actually no worse a way of looking at things than the current one, because according to at least one notable biologist, Stephen Jay Gould, there’s no such thing as a fish (see, e.g., the BBC QI episode “H for Hoax”). Lots of “fish” are more closely related to land animals than to each other. The modern definition basically boils down to the old one, with caveats of “but not those!”
bookworm0812 about 1 year ago
Except muskrat is meat. Today is a Lenten Friday. Not supposed to have meat today.
LadyPeterW about 1 year ago
But on St. Patrick’s Day, which is a Friday this year, Catholics can have their corned beef. Some Pope gave Catholics a pass on No Meat Fridays for good ol’ St. Pat.
jango about 1 year ago
Muskrat Love…haven’t heard that song in years, and probably for good reason.
eolan59 about 1 year ago
The same was done with capybaras.
ladykat about 1 year ago
Shades of Granny Clampett!
Frank Burns Eats Worms about 1 year ago
A rodent on the lips, a lifetime on the hips.
Doug K about 1 year ago
Eating Sammy and Susie?
raybarb44 about 1 year ago
If you are starving, food is food….
zippykatz about 1 year ago
Worst song ever!
TonysSon about 1 year ago
And the one that messed up Twitter is a different kind of MuskRat.
rwpleva1279 Premium Member about 1 year ago
Y’all know, of course, that “Muskrat Love” is a goofy song from the 70’s by Captain and Tennille. I suppose that dates me……
j.l.farmer about 1 year ago
I can hear Captain and Tennille right now singing their hit…..Muskrat Love!