Hmm, wonder if they can, or are likely to suspect an Anglo or Polish dude, Chinese, or Navajo, of being an “illegal alien”? From reports, sorry haven’t read the actual law, it seems a tad “vague” for probable cause.
Illegal immigrants, and taking free advertising space - there’s some kind of commonality here.
Bruce, what different standard? We already treat criminals as well as or better than other countries. Are you suggesting we not treat them as criminals at all?
If folks on the left want us to allow more people into the country, they should work to change the laws, not look the other way when laws are broken.
This is starting to sound like WWII Germany. Even LEGAL US citizens can be arrested without cause. If they are hispanic & don’t have proper documentation on them they can be harassed for having the wrong skin color. Arizona is placing themselves up above federal law & should be ashamed for this racist law
It’s a mistake to place it all on the illegals. It’s all about supply and demand. Much like drugs, there will /always/ be a supply of illegal aliens as long as there’s a demand for them. Hit the companies who employ illegal aliens with massive fines. It the illegals can’t get work, they’ll likely stop crossing the border.
The whole “guest worker” BS is little more than a sham to allow companies to keep hiring otherwise illegals at a pitiful wage in despicable working conditions.
Illegal is illegal, period. At the same time, this brings out the “conservatives” error AND terror—national ID cards, computer chips in the buttocks- etc.
But then none of those “conservatives” have ever accidentally left the house without ID and been arrested and jailed solely because of the skin they were born in.
You seem to be just looking for something to hate. Seriously, what has an illegal immigrant ever done to you anyway? Its not like they broke into the country to steal something, they want to work and send money home. You know, Horatio Alger and all that.
Senor- might also look into AMERICAN RICH folks like Ford, and other corporations who moved their factories to Mexico to avoid paying those living wages here at home.
NAAAAARF! Appropriate documentation?! Of being a legal citizen?
Is this a bad time to point out this is the same State that also has the “Birther Bill” that just passed it’s House of Representatives?
Honey, they still don’t acknowledge Obama’s birth certificate as legitimate proof of citizenship. If they don’t accept a Hawaii certificate of live birth as proof of citizenship, ain’t no way they’re gonna accept your New Jersey driver’s licence to prove you ain’t sneakin’ in from El Salvador.
Si, Senor. I don’t normally download video, because my IP is slower than teabaggers, and I split from GEICO a long time ago. Love the gecko- but he wouldn’t have run and hidden!
Dalai Lama has some very good statements on selflessness, also about respecting folks with other religions–WHO ACTUALLY OBSERVE THEIR PRINCIPLES! That happens to be driving me bats**t after their prayer here at the “tea party” for “God” to destroy “Islam and their false God”
We already have had our first example of the effect of this law - and it isn’t even signed!! Abdon is a commercial truck driver. He pulled into a weigh station to have the truck weighed. He was asked for his papers; he gives them his commercial driver’s license, bill of lading, etc. The demanded proof he was an American Citizen. When he had no proof, he was handcuffed, picked up by Immigration and locked in a cell. His wife had to leave work, go home, get their birth certificates, and go down to immigration. When he was able to prove he was born in Fresno he was released.
Note: Abdon had not committed a crime when someone demanded his papers.
Pup, just googled “birther movement” and second listing was Wikipedia” quite extensive, with a shot of Obama’s birth certificate. It’s fancier than mine from Washington state, and just as official.
Facts are facts, what are YOU afraid of? Right, facts!
Wow! I just googled Wikipedia Birther and Wikipedia won’t allow any mention of the Birther controversy…Wonder what Wikipedia is scared of? The same thing the Governor of hawaii and the MSM is scared of?
I wanted to post a link to that “wonderful” Certificate of Live Birth that everyone touts as “surefire” proof that Obama’s Preganant mother made it from Kenya in time to have him born on American Soil…I guess I’ll just point out that the average deed of automobile ownership has more information on it than Obama’s “Certificate of Live Birth” ; which is why the Hawaiian Department of Records has a long time policy of distributing that document to people who claim to have lost their original or need such documentation for employment, etc….
There’s even space there for a nice doodle…
Maybe a Hammer and Sickle in honor of GranMa and GranPa?
Does it say if he was a Buick or a Dodge? It would be ironic if it said “Ford”…Considering they didn’t need a bail-out…
You’re right, CorFrog; I believe he’s a man who believes he doesn’t have an original American Birth Certificate…Wonder why he doesn’t come clean?
If he lost his, like Bruce did - no crime there…But, then why the panic when the question was first brought up? Why the emergency “un-veiling” of the above pictured document? Why the un-preparedness on the question of his Citizenship?
If there is an original showing the Doctors present, the Hospital where birth took place, Mother and childs finger-prints, baby feet-prints, etc. (like the three documents I have that register my birth) then why not show it
sometime during the last 24 months? What is he, too proud to withstand public scrutiny? Who does he think he is?
While we’re at it…let’s see his college transcripts and registration papers…
His medical records…
Take a good look at most birth certificates. What information is actually missing from Obama’s? You have the child’s name, parent’s name & race, time and place of birth, and the date the certificate was filed. What more is there to add? What’s missing? Can anyone give an example of a birth certificate form Honolulu county of the same time frame as Obama’s that has more information?
Pup said “There’s even space there for a nice doodle… ”
That’s it? That’s your argument? There’s not enough to fill the page? I again ask: What’s missing? Can anyone give an example of a birth certificate form Honolulu county of the same time frame as Obama’s that has more information?
Pup went on to say “Maybe a Hammer and Sickle in honor of GranMa and GranPa?”
Come on, we’re 10 years into the new millennium. We’ve known for decades that communism was just a “red herring.” It amazes me that some people are still stupid enough to continue it.
^Are you equating Barack Obama with Jesus, Caveman?
As a side note: Jewish people were very fastidious about keeping records of their lineage; it was linked to privelleges and duties in their Society. Hence the two genealogical records attributable to Jesus found in the Book of Matthew and the Book of Luke. You see, Caveperson, for about 4000 years the Jewish people had been expecting a Messiah and they used to consider it important to keep track of their people and their Biblical Promises.
Bruce4671 said, 1 day ago
@PlainBill: That’s a very interesting story. Care to post a link to a news source or a police report or something that will give your story some credence?I looked, google and bing and …. But, no story that comes close to what you claim.”
Looks like google in the UK must be special. :-| < — click for article.
^ You’re welcome. Nah, Google works according a specific algorithm (Bing probably along something similar). It’s possible when you searched it simply didn’t kick up a result or perhaps the search criteria was too broad.
Yeah, getting impartial news nowadays is rather difficult. Straight reporting of facts perhaps only from Reuters & AP. BBC is good but even they are accused of lack of impartiality by whichever “side” feels misrepresented (I’d say they’re still pretty good). The UK is no different to the US as regards news outlets being partial to a brand of politics.
Re immigration. I’m biased on this point, as I am a migrant. I concede there is no easy solution for all parties, be it illegal migrants or legal residents. However, I’m dead set against criminalising illegal immigrants. Sure, they’re breaking labour & residency laws but by criminalising them, you push those most vulnerable in it to the darkest recesses of society. This is why you find a rather higher percentage of real criminal activity emanating from that underworld. Their movements are curtailed, so they will be likely to be drawn to break other laws. A fairer, flatter world is the only solution but until then…
Illegal immigrants are a problem and, since they are breaking the law, they are already criminals. On the other hand, to be required to carry ID at all times goes against everything that this country stands for. Such a law would be abused the first day of its enactment by some cop with an attitude and no common sense. The Arizona law is not perfect, but at least they are trying to solve a problem that the feds are ignoring for the sake of potential voters. And Arizona can pass whatever law they wish so long as it does not violate their state constitution. States joining the union did not give up their sovreignity .
If I remember correctly the Spanish explored and settled what is now Arizona nearly 300 years before the US existed. We stole that territory from Mexico after the Mexican War which was fought in large part to gain more territory for the expansion of slavery. Maybe people are just coming back to land that once belonged to them.
Dtroutma about 14 years ago
Hmm, wonder if they can, or are likely to suspect an Anglo or Polish dude, Chinese, or Navajo, of being an “illegal alien”? From reports, sorry haven’t read the actual law, it seems a tad “vague” for probable cause.
SClark55 Premium Member about 14 years ago
Illegal immigrants, and taking free advertising space - there’s some kind of commonality here.
Bruce, what different standard? We already treat criminals as well as or better than other countries. Are you suggesting we not treat them as criminals at all?
If folks on the left want us to allow more people into the country, they should work to change the laws, not look the other way when laws are broken.
Dapperdan61 Premium Member about 14 years ago
This is starting to sound like WWII Germany. Even LEGAL US citizens can be arrested without cause. If they are hispanic & don’t have proper documentation on them they can be harassed for having the wrong skin color. Arizona is placing themselves up above federal law & should be ashamed for this racist law
fallacyside about 14 years ago
^ I have a solution: require ALL citizens to carry appropriate ID at all times. ;^)
This is where we are at in America…
find excuses when illegal aliens and their American abettors break the laws.
Our Federal and State Governments claim to be legal entities; yet, they do not enforce their laws.
Hmmmmm…..
We can’t do simple things for any amount of money (close the borders); but we can control the climate…
Jason Allen about 14 years ago
It’s a mistake to place it all on the illegals. It’s all about supply and demand. Much like drugs, there will /always/ be a supply of illegal aliens as long as there’s a demand for them. Hit the companies who employ illegal aliens with massive fines. It the illegals can’t get work, they’ll likely stop crossing the border.
The whole “guest worker” BS is little more than a sham to allow companies to keep hiring otherwise illegals at a pitiful wage in despicable working conditions.
Dtroutma about 14 years ago
Illegal is illegal, period. At the same time, this brings out the “conservatives” error AND terror—national ID cards, computer chips in the buttocks- etc.
Be careful what you wish for?
chatoyant about 14 years ago
But then none of those “conservatives” have ever accidentally left the house without ID and been arrested and jailed solely because of the skin they were born in.
You seem to be just looking for something to hate. Seriously, what has an illegal immigrant ever done to you anyway? Its not like they broke into the country to steal something, they want to work and send money home. You know, Horatio Alger and all that.
biemmezeta about 14 years ago
We have to do what we have to do. Are you against the police and for drug trafficers??
Dtroutma about 14 years ago
Senor- might also look into AMERICAN RICH folks like Ford, and other corporations who moved their factories to Mexico to avoid paying those living wages here at home.
CorosiveFrog Premium Member about 14 years ago
Who needs racial profiling to find an alien, they should be easy to find!
If it has three eyes, green skin and antenaes, it’s an alien.
:D
Wildcard24365 about 14 years ago
NAAAAARF! Appropriate documentation?! Of being a legal citizen?
Is this a bad time to point out this is the same State that also has the “Birther Bill” that just passed it’s House of Representatives?
Honey, they still don’t acknowledge Obama’s birth certificate as legitimate proof of citizenship. If they don’t accept a Hawaii certificate of live birth as proof of citizenship, ain’t no way they’re gonna accept your New Jersey driver’s licence to prove you ain’t sneakin’ in from El Salvador.
Dtroutma about 14 years ago
Si, Senor. I don’t normally download video, because my IP is slower than teabaggers, and I split from GEICO a long time ago. Love the gecko- but he wouldn’t have run and hidden!
Dalai Lama has some very good statements on selflessness, also about respecting folks with other religions–WHO ACTUALLY OBSERVE THEIR PRINCIPLES! That happens to be driving me bats**t after their prayer here at the “tea party” for “God” to destroy “Islam and their false God”
Yep, real edurcatid folks in that thar T-party!
PlainBill about 14 years ago
We already have had our first example of the effect of this law - and it isn’t even signed!! Abdon is a commercial truck driver. He pulled into a weigh station to have the truck weighed. He was asked for his papers; he gives them his commercial driver’s license, bill of lading, etc. The demanded proof he was an American Citizen. When he had no proof, he was handcuffed, picked up by Immigration and locked in a cell. His wife had to leave work, go home, get their birth certificates, and go down to immigration. When he was able to prove he was born in Fresno he was released.
Note: Abdon had not committed a crime when someone demanded his papers.
CorosiveFrog Premium Member about 14 years ago
Wildcard nailed it!
Dtroutma about 14 years ago
Pup, just googled “birther movement” and second listing was Wikipedia” quite extensive, with a shot of Obama’s birth certificate. It’s fancier than mine from Washington state, and just as official.
Facts are facts, what are YOU afraid of? Right, facts!
fallacyside about 14 years ago
Wow! I just googled Wikipedia Birther and Wikipedia won’t allow any mention of the Birther controversy…Wonder what Wikipedia is scared of? The same thing the Governor of hawaii and the MSM is scared of?
I wanted to post a link to that “wonderful” Certificate of Live Birth that everyone touts as “surefire” proof that Obama’s Preganant mother made it from Kenya in time to have him born on American Soil…I guess I’ll just point out that the average deed of automobile ownership has more information on it than Obama’s “Certificate of Live Birth” ; which is why the Hawaiian Department of Records has a long time policy of distributing that document to people who claim to have lost their original or need such documentation for employment, etc….
Excellent, madtrout, Thank you!
from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barack_Obama_citizenship_conspiracy_theories
There’s even space there for a nice doodle… Maybe a Hammer and Sickle in honor of GranMa and GranPa?
Does it say if he was a Buick or a Dodge? It would be ironic if it said “Ford”…Considering they didn’t need a bail-out…
You’re right, CorFrog; I believe he’s a man who believes he doesn’t have an original American Birth Certificate…Wonder why he doesn’t come clean? If he lost his, like Bruce did - no crime there…But, then why the panic when the question was first brought up? Why the emergency “un-veiling” of the above pictured document? Why the un-preparedness on the question of his Citizenship? If there is an original showing the Doctors present, the Hospital where birth took place, Mother and childs finger-prints, baby feet-prints, etc. (like the three documents I have that register my birth) then why not show it sometime during the last 24 months? What is he, too proud to withstand public scrutiny? Who does he think he is? While we’re at it…let’s see his college transcripts and registration papers… His medical records…
Jason Allen about 14 years ago
Take a good look at most birth certificates. What information is actually missing from Obama’s? You have the child’s name, parent’s name & race, time and place of birth, and the date the certificate was filed. What more is there to add? What’s missing? Can anyone give an example of a birth certificate form Honolulu county of the same time frame as Obama’s that has more information?
zekedog55 about 14 years ago
Row, row, row your boat, gently down the stream…
Jason Allen about 14 years ago
Pup said “There’s even space there for a nice doodle… ”
That’s it? That’s your argument? There’s not enough to fill the page? I again ask: What’s missing? Can anyone give an example of a birth certificate form Honolulu county of the same time frame as Obama’s that has more information?
Pup went on to say “Maybe a Hammer and Sickle in honor of GranMa and GranPa?”
Come on, we’re 10 years into the new millennium. We’ve known for decades that communism was just a “red herring.” It amazes me that some people are still stupid enough to continue it.
CorosiveFrog Premium Member about 14 years ago
Pup; you proved it: it’s not about Obama’s actual birth certificate, but about what people think he believes.
CorosiveFrog Premium Member about 14 years ago
^You’d never believe any birth certificate coming from Obama unless it says he’sborn in kenya, so why should anyone try to convince you?
fallacyside about 14 years ago
^Are you equating Barack Obama with Jesus, Caveman?
As a side note: Jewish people were very fastidious about keeping records of their lineage; it was linked to privelleges and duties in their Society. Hence the two genealogical records attributable to Jesus found in the Book of Matthew and the Book of Luke. You see, Caveperson, for about 4000 years the Jewish people had been expecting a Messiah and they used to consider it important to keep track of their people and their Biblical Promises.
OmqR-IV.0 about 14 years ago
Bruce4671 said, 1 day ago @PlainBill: That’s a very interesting story. Care to post a link to a news source or a police report or something that will give your story some credence? I looked, google and bing and …. But, no story that comes close to what you claim.”
Looks like google in the UK must be special. :-| < — click for article.
CorosiveFrog Premium Member about 14 years ago
Sooky Rottweiler says;
Flea baggers, ROFL!!!
OmqR-IV.0 about 14 years ago
^ You’re welcome. Nah, Google works according a specific algorithm (Bing probably along something similar). It’s possible when you searched it simply didn’t kick up a result or perhaps the search criteria was too broad.
Yeah, getting impartial news nowadays is rather difficult. Straight reporting of facts perhaps only from Reuters & AP. BBC is good but even they are accused of lack of impartiality by whichever “side” feels misrepresented (I’d say they’re still pretty good). The UK is no different to the US as regards news outlets being partial to a brand of politics.
Re immigration. I’m biased on this point, as I am a migrant. I concede there is no easy solution for all parties, be it illegal migrants or legal residents. However, I’m dead set against criminalising illegal immigrants. Sure, they’re breaking labour & residency laws but by criminalising them, you push those most vulnerable in it to the darkest recesses of society. This is why you find a rather higher percentage of real criminal activity emanating from that underworld. Their movements are curtailed, so they will be likely to be drawn to break other laws. A fairer, flatter world is the only solution but until then…
Rocky Premium Member about 14 years ago
Illegal immigrants are a problem and, since they are breaking the law, they are already criminals. On the other hand, to be required to carry ID at all times goes against everything that this country stands for. Such a law would be abused the first day of its enactment by some cop with an attitude and no common sense. The Arizona law is not perfect, but at least they are trying to solve a problem that the feds are ignoring for the sake of potential voters. And Arizona can pass whatever law they wish so long as it does not violate their state constitution. States joining the union did not give up their sovreignity .
John Foster Premium Member almost 14 years ago
If I remember correctly the Spanish explored and settled what is now Arizona nearly 300 years before the US existed. We stole that territory from Mexico after the Mexican War which was fought in large part to gain more territory for the expansion of slavery. Maybe people are just coming back to land that once belonged to them.
Dtroutma almost 14 years ago
Arizona was the site of the westernmost battle of the Civil War.
runar almost 14 years ago
Let’s all go to Arizona without wallets, act “suspicious” and clog their courts.
TruthfulTheocracy almost 14 years ago
Juan Crow.
fallacyside almost 14 years ago
Viva los Mexicanos! But, down with American Libs!
rekam Premium Member almost 14 years ago
Scowl, if you don’t like American Libs you can always move to the “safe” country of Mexico.
fallacyside almost 14 years ago
I’m happy right here. How ‘bout you?