Comments (35) (Please sign in to comment)

1. 

   Night-Gaunt49 said, over 1 year ago

   Depends on which enterprise an which Deathstar. Only one shot from the DS main weapon an the Enterprise of any vintage would be blasted to space dust.
2. 

   Sack of Rabid Weasels said, over 1 year ago

   It’s already been discussed.
3. 

   jimmyh43105 said, over 1 year ago

   But is the photon torpedo bigger than the hole that’s the size of a whomp-rat? If it is, the Enterprise is in trouble.
4. 

   D-Tritus Debris said, over 1 year ago

   No Enterprise (particularly not the Sovereign-class Enterprise-E) could stand a chance against the Death Star. It’s far too big and would need to be incredibly fast in order to begin any kind of approach. And also, it’s too big and impossible to maneuver at that level. Maybe a shuttlecraft could last if it got close enough to launch a photon torpedo down the exposed control duct.
5. 

   alfuso said, over 1 year ago

   I’d bet on both of them.
6. 

   Brad Bubolz said, over 1 year ago

   I must agree the photon torpedo is too big for the exhaust port and the enterprise itself is too big to maneuver inside the super structure
7. 

   Tog said, over 1 year ago

   You need the Doctor’s TARDIS and materialise inside the Death Star in order to start a chain reaction of destruction from the inside as witnessed at the start of the last Christmas special. Which reminds me, the new series of Woo is about to start here. That’s Saturday evening sorted then.
8. 

   JimmyTheHand said, over 1 year ago

   would either stand a chance against Lexx ?
9. 

   Tue Elung-Jensen said, over 1 year ago

   @Tog

   “Woo”. Is that some asien copy version?
10. 

    Brian Ransom said, over 1 year ago

    One shot from the death star and the Enterprise would be history! Besides, Vader could choke Picard from a distance!
11. 

    ghostkeeper said, over 1 year ago

    Eh, on the face of it the Death Star would win, but then, think about it! The first Death Star was so poorly planned that ONE bomb dropped down a shaft blows it up. The second had a force field, sure, but again poor planning; the energy source for it is located on a planet instead of on the Death Star, and is the building for that energy source itself protected by a force field? Nope! As for Vader using the ‘dark side of the Force." really now . . . he didn’t use it to stop the bomb from dropping, he didn’t use it to blow the bomb up before it hit the central power core . . . with such demonstrated INCOMPETENCE as the Empire has repeatedly shown, how the heck did it ever manage to establish itself? I begin to think the WW2 Enterprise could do the job, let alone Star Trek’s!
12. 

    ghostkeeper said, over 1 year ago

    I also begin to think Darth Vader is a Septimus Snape. Think about it; Anakin knows a Jedi Knight is ‘destined’ to turn to the dark side, knows the Old Republic is ‘destined’ to fall, so he precipitates it; all the killing, all the evil, all to first create the Empire, then to destroy it!
13. 

    Egg Man said, over 1 year ago

    Capt Kirk would have come up with a way to defeat the Death Star. Even if he had to cheat and rewrite the script.
14. 

    olddog1 said, over 1 year ago

    You’re a geek if you even show up for the conversation, regardless of your choice.
15. 

    johnzakour said, over 1 year ago

    :)
16. Load the rest of the comments (20).