Legendary journalist Seymour Hersh reports that Pakistan was holding Obama Bin Laden under house arrest when Navy seals shot him like a fish in a barrel, and threw parts of his body out of their helicopter over the mountains.
Well, Hersch’s story answers a few of the weaker parts of the original story. Like how he managed to live in the city where the Pakistan military was so strong.
Because the had the backing of the Pakistani Intelligence Service.
I doubt Osama is dead yet. I believe he was taken to Diego Garcia and is being actively interrogated. Of course, he’ll have to be killed, quietly, after he is of no more use as the administration has already said he’s dead. To tell the truth, I rather hope that’s how it is.
I liked the original Arabian Nights version better, especially the part where the Djinn of the West sealed Osama bin Laden in a great jug with 108 curses and Seal of Solomon on it, and caused a great roc to carry it out over the Indian Ocean, where it was dropped into the sea, Or handed over to sea monsters. Whatever. The new version is all too realistic.
Mr Rall reported on an article published around 11 May in the London Review of Books by the Pulitzer Prize winning journalist who covered the My Lai victory by US soldiers. But Mr Rall didn’t give any links..http://www.lrb.co.uk/v37/n10/seymour-m-hersh/the-killing-of-osama-bin-laden.The London Independent first reported the story as true, just because it was loaded with facts and evidence and fit what we know much better than the official While House Version..The first New York Times article was White House Calls Bin Laden Article ‘Outright Falsehoods’.http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2015/05/11/us/politics/ap-us-white-house-bin-laden.html.The White House paints Hersh as a tinfoil-hat wearing conspiracy theorist. And we all know that whatever the White House says is right. If the White House decrees that up is down, only the tinfoil-hat wearers will continue to scream that up is up..The next day, however, the New York Times had some more articles about the Hersh article:.http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/12/magazine/the-detail-in-seymour-hershs-bin-laden-story-that-rings-true.html
Actually, if W had simply gone over to the Hindu Kush (or wherever) with Pakistani help and killed the guy, we could have avoided a couple of trillion dollars of invasion and occupation expenses, saved thousands of American lives, prevented thousands of war injuries to service men and women, saved hundreds of thousands of Iraqi and Afghan lives, and preserved some shred of US global credibility. Who cares if the actual operation was covert? Who cares if the Pakistanis helped? If true, the Hirsch story doesn’t bother me in the slightest. What bothers me is that killing bin Laden was the last thing on W and Cheney’s mind when they started the Iraq war with lies and deceptions. They intended to invade Iraq from the start and fabricated “evidence” to justify it. That’s way more disturbing than killing some Islamic idiot with help from other Islamic idiots.
Darsan54 Premium Member about 9 years ago
Well, Hersch’s story answers a few of the weaker parts of the original story. Like how he managed to live in the city where the Pakistan military was so strong.
hawgowar about 9 years ago
Because the had the backing of the Pakistani Intelligence Service.
I doubt Osama is dead yet. I believe he was taken to Diego Garcia and is being actively interrogated. Of course, he’ll have to be killed, quietly, after he is of no more use as the administration has already said he’s dead. To tell the truth, I rather hope that’s how it is.
wcorvi about 9 years ago
I saw Osama in a Flying Saucer on the way to Mars, with JFK and Elvis.
King_Shark about 9 years ago
Osama bin Laden is now a fictional character.
mattro65 about 9 years ago
We created him. It’s only right that we destroyed him.
Anarcissie about 9 years ago
I liked the original Arabian Nights version better, especially the part where the Djinn of the West sealed Osama bin Laden in a great jug with 108 curses and Seal of Solomon on it, and caused a great roc to carry it out over the Indian Ocean, where it was dropped into the sea, Or handed over to sea monsters. Whatever. The new version is all too realistic.
Ted Rall creator about 9 years ago
I can’t believe no one thought the idea of terrorist body parts raining over the Hindu Kush was funny.
Mickey and Delia about 9 years ago
Mr Rall reported on an article published around 11 May in the London Review of Books by the Pulitzer Prize winning journalist who covered the My Lai victory by US soldiers. But Mr Rall didn’t give any links..http://www.lrb.co.uk/v37/n10/seymour-m-hersh/the-killing-of-osama-bin-laden.The London Independent first reported the story as true, just because it was loaded with facts and evidence and fit what we know much better than the official While House Version..The first New York Times article was White House Calls Bin Laden Article ‘Outright Falsehoods’.http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2015/05/11/us/politics/ap-us-white-house-bin-laden.html.The White House paints Hersh as a tinfoil-hat wearing conspiracy theorist. And we all know that whatever the White House says is right. If the White House decrees that up is down, only the tinfoil-hat wearers will continue to scream that up is up..The next day, however, the New York Times had some more articles about the Hersh article:.http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/12/magazine/the-detail-in-seymour-hershs-bin-laden-story-that-rings-true.html
mattro65 about 9 years ago
@G KruseWhat be moran?
NathandeGargoyle about 9 years ago
Who?
AlanMintaka about 9 years ago
Yes! Hersh should know, because he…
Wait. How’d he know again?
Well, it doesn’t matter, as long as the report makes Obama look bad. Fair and Balanced,
twclix about 9 years ago
Actually, if W had simply gone over to the Hindu Kush (or wherever) with Pakistani help and killed the guy, we could have avoided a couple of trillion dollars of invasion and occupation expenses, saved thousands of American lives, prevented thousands of war injuries to service men and women, saved hundreds of thousands of Iraqi and Afghan lives, and preserved some shred of US global credibility. Who cares if the actual operation was covert? Who cares if the Pakistanis helped? If true, the Hirsch story doesn’t bother me in the slightest. What bothers me is that killing bin Laden was the last thing on W and Cheney’s mind when they started the Iraq war with lies and deceptions. They intended to invade Iraq from the start and fabricated “evidence” to justify it. That’s way more disturbing than killing some Islamic idiot with help from other Islamic idiots.
echoraven about 9 years ago
I’m sorry; that was darn funny!