Doonesbury by Garry Trudeau

Doonesbury

Comments (35) (Please sign in to comment)

  1. Newshound41

    Newshound41 said, about 1 year ago

    This is where this arc has a problem with the storyline. Last week Mel’s father advised her not to “dwell.”
    Most of the readers knew he was referring to the sexual assault.
    Now he acts as if this is all new to him and he had no idea how traumatized Mel was.

  2. simpsonfan2

    simpsonfan2 said, about 1 year ago

    Eventually some female soldier is going to get raped, and will not bother with the Chain of Command, but take matters into her own hands. And shoot the rapist with a lot of bullets.

  3. Borntalkingback

    Borntalkingback said, about 1 year ago

    @simpsonfan2

    What makes you think this is not already happening?

  4. Mike31g

    Mike31g said, about 1 year ago

    A 40 year rerun.
    http://www.gocomics.com/doonesbury/1973/03/07
    BDs college project
    Mike

  5. Mike31g

    Mike31g said, about 1 year ago

    Melissa speaks up
    http://www.gocomics.com/doonesbury/2007/06/28

    Counseling Melissa
    Mike

  6. TheSkulker

    TheSkulker GoComics PRO Member said, about 1 year ago

    @Newshound41

    No, it is not contradictory at all. It just shows how clueless and dismissive her father is about the trauma of rape.

  7. Astolat

    Astolat said, about 1 year ago

    I think Newshound41 has a point. Regardless of whether he understands it, her Dad can’t at the same time say “don’t dwell” and then say “I had no idea”. Apart from anything else, she was presumably at home on some form of sick leave when in counselling, so presumably he at least knew that.
    You can make an argument that he knew she was ill from stress but didn’t know what; however, unless there is a strip I’ve missed from that time which explains Dad’s reaction, I’d tend to agree with Newshound41 that it is an inconsistency. GT probably thought it was worth it for the joke!

  8. Sportymonk

    Sportymonk said, about 1 year ago

    Sad that this is a re-run from years ago and is still just as true today. News the other day had the military with lots of talk of accountability but in the end it was just talk and paperwork.

  9. Kip W

    Kip W said, about 1 year ago

    He knew it happened but not how much, maybe.

  10. Dr Dave

    Dr Dave said, about 1 year ago

    Put that on a recruiting poster…

  11. Fiendly Neighbourhood Terrorist

    Fiendly Neighbourhood Terrorist said, about 1 year ago

    Still in reruns, huh? Carry on, then…

  12. Kerovan

    Kerovan said, about 1 year ago

    @Astolat

    and those above
    I don’t see this as being inconsistent. He knows she went through counseling for some trauma, but might not know what kind of trauma. It’s just as likely he thinks it was for PTSD or something.

    As for her statement that the woman’s career is probably over, In every circumstance I know of the rapists career definitely was. I’m sure there is still some of that attitude in the military but nowhere near as much as this indicates. Bureaucracies change slowly, but they do change. Thankfully the attitude toward rape is one of the ones changing fastest.

  13. Gokie5

    Gokie5 said, about 1 year ago

    I’ve never heard of a victim shooting his or her molester in the service. Must have happened sometime, though . . .

  14. Kaffekup

    Kaffekup said, about 1 year ago

    As I recall, in her case, it was the commander himself that was the rapist. Didn’t she (or her counselor) refer to it as “command rape”?
    I would think her father would take it more seriously. Cavalier as one may be about the subject, I’m sure that falls away when it’s one’s own daughter.

  15. Night-Gaunt49

    Night-Gaunt49 said, about 1 year ago

    @simpsonfan2

    Then she gets court martialed and Ft. Leavenworth if she is lucky.

  16. Load the rest of the comments (20).