Stone Soup by Jan Eliot for October 17, 2014
Transcript:
Joan: Holly, you can't just take my topic ideas, string them together and call it a term paper! Joan: You need to pick one, research it at the library or online, and then, IN YOUR OWN WORDS, write about what you learned. Holly: If it all exists in books and online ALREADY, why does my teacher need ME to re-create it?? Joan: Because. Holly: I KNEW it.
ORMouseworks over 9 years ago
Holly, Holly, Holly…don’t drag your feet over a history (?) assignment. There is so much to learn out there! It will give your thirsty brain a chance to stretch and fill your learning-cells! And, who knows, you might see some of your male classmates at the library… ;)
Templo S.U.D. over 9 years ago
It had to be “because.”
Agent54 over 9 years ago
Why?? to see if you understand it or just parrot it. Many a “smart” person in school could parrot facts and history all day long but never could learn from it.
Boots at the Boar Premium Member over 9 years ago
Most of the new knowledge tends to be preceded by a lengthy review of the old knowledge to both demonstrate the competency of the author and to make sure everyone is on the same page. It can also flesh out a publication or technical report when you have nothing to report but failure.
Observer fo Irony over 9 years ago
And to be sure to use your own words get a thesaurus and use words that are not in there.
ShadowBeast Premium Member over 9 years ago
To show proof that you learned about it.
jeanie5448 over 9 years ago
if she had actually done the work instead of trying to wrangle someone else to do the work, she would be finished by now and have all this free time.
jeanie5448 over 9 years ago
Also how old is she supposed to be?? I have a 12 year old grandson that has this same kind of strange logic. haha
KEA over 9 years ago
it’s really not about learning facts (altho it would be nice to have some stick and give the student some perspective*) it’s more about learning how to analyze facts and communicate what you’ve learned in an effective manner.
*education is (or should be) about the “big” view of the world around you – how it is now, how it came to be this way, and where it’s likely to go, so that a person can make wise choices for themselves and society ; NOT about learning simple facts and skills that help doing a job – that’s TRAINING.
crazyliberal over 9 years ago
I seem to remember this story line as a repeat!
calliopejane over 9 years ago
Because this is about you learning skills, not making a great contribution to history or literature.
All those math problems have already been solved by other people too, you know.
This is called “school.”
kab2rb over 9 years ago
Holly I wondered that myself why rewrite an article what the author writes felt as if I buttered what the writer wrote. I know a way of learning.
Comic Minister Premium Member over 9 years ago
I see.
Kathy M T M Premium Member over 9 years ago
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Sorka8 over 9 years ago
Worst answer ever to a student
She Mc over 9 years ago
I couldn’t wait to have kids & be able to say ‘because I said so’ my mother said it to me all the time, there’s no clever retort to that!
Kathy M T M Premium Member over 9 years ago
being bored? O_o