When my parents were kids, Christmas gifts were mostly tokens… and the celebration was in the church, plus “all you want to eat”. When my cohort were kids, Christmas gifts were real, but the emphasis (from the adults) was on the church service and, yes, the edibles. When our kids were young, the emphasis was on the gifts, with some church. Now that THEY have kids (and in one case a grandkid), the church part is… gone (I’m fine with that), the food part is iffy because of dietary restrictions… and the presents are surely more 85% of the celebration.
Does that mean the GOP will quit carping about “supply chain” issues?
Or maybe start focusing on NOT depending on a consumer economy? Maybe that’s the right approach. Our economy’s been broken for a long time depending on people going out and buying more and more stuff they don’t need.
I actually agree with Goodwyn on this one. Christmas has become nothing more than an exercise of consumerism. If we stopped buying gifts for people our economy would crash. I don’t think that’s a good thing at all.
Buy gifts that are made in America. They’re not trapped inside shipping containers that came from overseas. Don’t you people believe in America First anymore?
Al, is there anything called “cause and effect” in your world? “The invisible hand of the free market” spent the last 50 years pushing the idea that Christmas is about: Presents. Were you pushing back on that the entire time or was that “Anti-capitalist COMMUNISM! SOCIALISM! DAMN LIBERALS!” ?
Asking for about the 3 generations of Americans who are younger than you.
I like Christmas, and if we can be just a little kinder to each other on that one day, it is worth it. However, kids wanting presents are a by-product of our consumer, marketing-driven culture.
““For this is how God loved the world: He gave his one and only Son, so that everyone who believes in him will not perish but have eternal life.”John 3:16 NLT
Concretionist over 2 years ago
When my parents were kids, Christmas gifts were mostly tokens… and the celebration was in the church, plus “all you want to eat”. When my cohort were kids, Christmas gifts were real, but the emphasis (from the adults) was on the church service and, yes, the edibles. When our kids were young, the emphasis was on the gifts, with some church. Now that THEY have kids (and in one case a grandkid), the church part is… gone (I’m fine with that), the food part is iffy because of dietary restrictions… and the presents are surely more 85% of the celebration.
Walter Kocker Premium Member over 2 years ago
But wait, wasn’t He born in July?
braindead Premium Member over 2 years ago
Is Goodwyn implying that Christmas is about something other than presents?
VegaAlopex over 2 years ago
Over the last decade I’ve had Christmas without presents. Presents are not necessary.
baroden Premium Member over 2 years ago
Does that mean the GOP will quit carping about “supply chain” issues?
Or maybe start focusing on NOT depending on a consumer economy? Maybe that’s the right approach. Our economy’s been broken for a long time depending on people going out and buying more and more stuff they don’t need.
Patjade over 2 years ago
It’s all about the stuff and commercialism and not the reason behind it, right Al?
Valiant1943 Premium Member over 2 years ago
That is why I’ve found the “Put Christ back into Christmas” bumper stickers so hypocritical
The Nodding Head over 2 years ago
Gosh, the annual winter solstice commercial orgy might be truncated? Mammon will be disappointed.
mourdac Premium Member over 2 years ago
At least Goodwyn didn’t make this about the Dem/Fem/Lib/Socialist/LGBTQ/Enviro/non-Christian/non-White wackos attacks on Christmas …/s
RonnieAThompson Premium Member over 2 years ago
Therefore the Lord himself shall give you a sign; Behold, a virgin shall conceive, and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel. Isaiah 7:14 KJV.
ChristopherBurns over 2 years ago
I actually agree with Goodwyn on this one. Christmas has become nothing more than an exercise of consumerism. If we stopped buying gifts for people our economy would crash. I don’t think that’s a good thing at all.
Radish the wordsmith over 2 years ago
Maybe if you lying right wingers had not killed a million Americans with covid we would not be in this situation.
fusilier over 2 years ago
There really was a “War On Christmas.”
WalMart won.
fusilier
James 2:24
B 8671 over 2 years ago
Spoken like a snot nosed, privileged brat!
ferddo over 2 years ago
Buy gifts that are made in America. They’re not trapped inside shipping containers that came from overseas. Don’t you people believe in America First anymore?
Vidrinath Premium Member over 2 years ago
Al, is there anything called “cause and effect” in your world? “The invisible hand of the free market” spent the last 50 years pushing the idea that Christmas is about: Presents. Were you pushing back on that the entire time or was that “Anti-capitalist COMMUNISM! SOCIALISM! DAMN LIBERALS!” ?
Asking for about the 3 generations of Americans who are younger than you.
Radish the wordsmith over 2 years ago
Evil Republicans are against Christ’s teachings of love thy neighbor and heal the sick and feed the poor.
freshmeet2030 over 2 years ago
… another unbelievable fairy tale, like the easter bunny and tooth fairy.
rs0204 Premium Member over 2 years ago
I like Christmas, and if we can be just a little kinder to each other on that one day, it is worth it. However, kids wanting presents are a by-product of our consumer, marketing-driven culture.
Kids repeat what they see.
tamrich59 over 2 years ago
““For this is how God loved the world: He gave his one and only Son, so that everyone who believes in him will not perish but have eternal life.”John 3:16 NLT