Stone Soup by Jan Eliot

Stone Soup

Recommended

Comments (21) (Please sign in to comment)

  1. Night-Gaunt49

    Night-Gaunt49 said, 5 months ago

    Give her advice, the rest Holly does herself or not. It is in her court.

  2. templo SUD

    templo SUD said, 5 months ago

    Oh no, Holly, you’re not making your mother’s sister do ALL the work, are you?

  3. Redkaycei Repoc

    Redkaycei Repoc said, 5 months ago

    @templo SUD

    Only if she can, only if she can………………….

  4. trekman58

    trekman58 said, 5 months ago

    …gotta start somewhere!

  5. psychlady

    psychlady said, 5 months ago

    Who’s name will go on this one?

  6. emjaycee

    emjaycee said, 5 months ago

    Anyone know what the topic is/was?

  7. lightenup

    lightenup said, 5 months ago

    Term papers are always easy for writers (I think that’s what Joan does). I was always much too concise and blunt to churn out 10 pages of words.

  8. whmIII

    whmIII said, 5 months ago

    Still trying to dodge it…

  9. Rx71Wm29

    Rx71Wm29 said, 5 months ago

    So, will Ms. Wingit offer Holly 1/4 or 1/8 credit when Holly tells her the paper is still not done? Wouldn’t surprise me.

  10. Macushlalondra

    Macushlalondra said, 5 months ago

    Give it up Holly, just accept your failing grade.

  11. Milestheglassguy

    Milestheglassguy said, 5 months ago

    I was thinking about this at the beginning of the story arc: most kids in middle school aren’t writing a 10 page paper on their own. Parents and siblings get roped onto doing most of the proof reading and editing until at least the beginning of high school, and some never stop.

  12. somebodyshort

    somebodyshort said, 5 months ago

    Good on Joan. I’m sure she’ll GUIDE, but Holly will do the work.

  13. Loy Wells

    Loy Wells said, 5 months ago

    She should have been given a “0” in the first place for cheating.

  14. UncaJim

    UncaJim said, 5 months ago

    @Miles;
    Even back in the dark ages of the ’50’s, we weren’t required to do a thousand word essay/report/critique until well into 11th grade, and depending on parents who never graduated high school was not an option. Copy and paste? psh…

  15. segullah

    segullah said, 5 months ago

    @Milestheglassguy

    having someone proofread your papers is the smart thing to do, and is encouraged at the highest levels of education….I did some for my hubby’s doctorate. It is a fresh set of eyes and if they can spell and spot grammar mistakes then they are the best ones. When we edit our own we are too close to it and don’t see the mistakes. Editing and rewriting are two very different things. Someone telling you that this sentence doesn’t make sense is different from them telling you what to write.
    Aunt Joan is a wonderful resource for Holly…if she probes and prompts Holly to think and write. Holly will learn so much if she also helps her to break the assignment/paper down to manageable bits.

  16. Load the rest of the comments (6).