Comments (26) (Please sign in to comment)

1. 

   Jim Kleinhans said, 6 months ago

   I don’t see how anyone could get excited about Harry Potter or the Lord Of The Rings.
2. 

   K.C. Fahel said, 6 months ago

   @Jim Kleinhans

   LOTR, yes; Potter, no.
3. 

   einarbt7 said, 6 months ago

   I’ll just have to Google “Harry Potter vs. LotR” now.
4. 

   rpmurray said, 6 months ago

   Both were huge snoozefests. I still haven’t watched both in their entirety because I keep falling asleep.
5. 

   PhoebeDog said, 6 months ago

   I must be in the minority, I loved them both but LOTR more.
6. 

   zoidknight said, 6 months ago

   @Jim Kleinhans

   You like the Kardishans, don’t you?
7. 

   zoidknight said, 6 months ago

   @rpmurray

   Sports is not real life either.
8. 

   zoidknight said, 6 months ago

   @PhoebeDog

   Yes, because as Geeks we are more highly evolved than these philistine neaderthals who think that reality TV is good.
9. 

   twypsi said, 6 months ago

   I think Jason has met his match.
10. 

    Xane_T said, 6 months ago

    I liked both (though there were far more plot holes and annoyances in HP for me than LOTR) but LOTR is much older and has a much larger and more diverse fanbase. I think Jason wins this round.
11. 

    Sardonis said, 6 months ago

    Eh—they were okay. I guess I’m not nerdy enough to really have much to comment on, but I preferred the Harry Potter movies—at least, the first 2. I haven’t watched all of them. I found the Lord of the Rings to be far too long. I read the Hobbit and started reading Lord of the Rings, but I found… get ready for it… that I liked David Eddings’ books better. Tolkien was great, but that was a LONG time ago. It would be awesome if they made a series of movies based on Belgarath and Polgara. Or even the Sparhawk series. Oh God—I’m sounding like a nerd! lol
12. 

    T_Lexi said, 6 months ago

    @zoidknight

    5 stars to you for the laugh-out-loud comment of the day! : D
13. 

    supersexyghotmew95 said, 6 months ago

    harry rules pireod
14. 

    pjez123 said, 6 months ago

    If you like Harry Potter, check out Limyaael’s fanfic – 7 humongous novels, and so well written that I don’t read canon Harry Potter anymore.

    http://www.fanfiction.net/u/895946/Lightning-on-the-Wave

    Start with Saving Connor (at the very bottom) – that’s the first novel – and then work towards “I’m also thy brother”. They’re amazing.
15. 

    Night-Gaunt49 said, 6 months ago

    @Jim Kleinhans

    I liked them both. No reason to have one over the other the Universe is vast, it can hold multitudes.
16. Load the rest of the comments (11).