For Better or For Worse by Lynn Johnston

?fh=0093a2655f90b0a4ffca792bfad6a936

Comments (16) Jump to Comments Form

  1. pschearer

    pschearerGenius_badge said, 5 months ago

    At first I was surprised when the Phila. Inquirer dropped FBOFW, but considering how weak and predictable the jokes have become, it is understandable.

    A few more days like this one and I will be dropping it from my subscription. The world doesn’t need two Family Circuses.

  2. ElainefromFlorida

    ElainefromFlorida said, 5 months ago

    Frankly, I’m enjoying FBOFW. I didn’t start reading it till about the time April was born, so this is all new to me. I’m also a mom, so I can really relate to comics like today’s.

  3. Macushlalondra

    MacushlalondraGenius_badge said, 5 months ago

    Sorry Elly but teaching the kids obedience and everything else is your job and John’s. That’s why you’re parents.

  4. prasrinivara

    prasrinivara said, 5 months ago

    However Macush, “boarding schools” (which do exist in Canada) were invented for the purpose of teaching children discipline/obedience.

  5. princepavel

    princepavel said, 5 months ago

    To me the fact that the Phily Inquirer dropped FBOFW says much more about the sad state of printed media than FBOFW. I’m sure the Inquirer will follow the path of many dying dailies all over the world. sigh.

  6. summerdog

    summerdog said, 5 months ago

    I don’t think that the kids could hear her because what she said to them is not in a neat little white balloon.

  7. pearlandpeach

    pearlandpeach said, 5 months ago

    it all started when I threw my brothers train engine out the second floor window. We developed the fine art of “fighting” and resented the intervention of parents. THEN it was a united front.

  8. jmworacle

    jmworacle said, 5 months ago

    The dog would probably easier to train. However, the parents need to have a consistent and loving hand in discipline.

  9. bluetopazcrystal

    bluetopazcrystal said, 5 months ago

    Hey NotNormanChubsyUbsy,
    I don’t read her as screaming irrationally. More like being a little overwhelmed at times. She’s portrayed as a good, understanding Mom, and we all have periods of frustration.

  10. Calvinsmom

    CalvinsmomGenius_badge said, 5 months ago

    I liked the original FBOFW much better. In this rendition, Elly is pissy and whiny and resentful about being a stay-at-home mom. I HAD to work when my kids were pre-school, and would have given anything to be able to stay home with them. I’m pretty much fed up with Elly’s constant self-pitying bad attitude. The original Elly had a much better sense of humor and handled life’s adversities better. This one is a case of arrested development.

  11. Coffee-Turtle

    Coffee-TurtleGenius_badge said, 5 months ago

    I wish I could compare the “original” and the “new” to see what you guys are talking about with the Elly character. Overall, I still enjoy this strip and it is still a nice trip down memory lane seeing everyone young and vibrant!

  12. pearlandpeach

    pearlandpeach said, 5 months ago

    Elly is the same character, Calvinsmom and NOtnorman are just older and see things differently, whether they know, or see it, or not.

  13. howtheduck

    howtheduck said, 5 months ago

    pearlandpeach is correct. Today’s comic strip is a reprint from the second year of the comic strip. There is no “original” vs. “new” comparison here.

  14. Rockyhammock

    Rockyhammock said, 5 months ago

    Original….New!! Maybe I missed something, but I thought this was the Original FBOFW just being rerun on the public, just as Peanuts is??

  15. Greeneyed Texan

    Greeneyed TexanGenius_badge said, 5 months ago

    Lynn Johnson had stated on her comics that she was going to redo the entire series with an alternative point of view. Whether or not she has stayed consistant or not–I don’t know cause this seems like the same one I read long ago.

  16. howtheduck

    howtheduck said, 5 months ago

    Greeneyedtxn and Rockyhammock. These are neither reprints like Peanuts, nor is this the entire series from an alternative point-of-view. Since September, 2008, Lynn Johnston has done approximately a 50% mixture of reprints from the first 2 years of her comic strip and new material close to the same art style as the reprints. Lynn Johnston calls the new material by the name “new-runs.”

    If you want to compare: June 6 - today is all reprint. May 31 - June 5 is all new-run.