Doonesbury by Garry Trudeau

?fh=dbd4141e49b4869a6dd8d8a0b98b09e1

Shop Collector’s Edition Doonesbury Framed Prints!

Comments (17) Jump to Comments Form

  1. CoolGuy2000

    CoolGuy2000 said, 3 months ago

    what? is he not happy for her? i’m kinda late.

  2. jonathanyoung

    jonathanyoungGenius_badge said, 3 months ago

    Is B. D. left-handed? He’s wearing his watch on the right wrist.

  3. edcoyote

    edcoyoteGenius_badge said, 3 months ago

    This is a weird one. She happily announces her progress, he replies like BD would She reacts in an angry condescending way.

    Their backstory is that she was harassed and had a problem with men in authority in the military. BD has seemed to flirt with her in the past, although I don’t know their ranks.

    All in all, I’m thinking she hasn’t progressed all that far, and the men in the sandbox might be in for trouble.

    –Ed

  4. diggitt

    diggitt said, 3 months ago

    It’s simpler than that. She can go back. He can’t.

  5. summerdog

    summerdog said, 3 months ago

    I think diggitt is correct on this call.

  6. pibfan868

    pibfan868Genius_badge said, 3 months ago

    I think she’s asking him if he’s managed to deal with his issues successfully–and he’s been surprised.

  7. Joe Allen Doty

    Joe Allen Doty said, 3 months ago

    I say that Melissa got her therapeutic advice from the “Oprah” show and one of the self-help gurus on it.

    She is definitely not ready to go back to active duty.

    B.D. could be ambidextrous and it be no big deal with where he wears his watch.

    I am a both-handed person and although I write with my right hand, I am more left-handed oriented.

  8. baslim_the_begger

    baslim_the_beggerGenius_badge said, 3 months ago

    I’m with diggit, too. But it is also about Melissa feeling that she has taken charge of her life and BD, not so much.

  9. BlueRaven

    BlueRaven said, 3 months ago

    Baslim, I think you’ve got it. The one-word question is more of an accusation that BD’s just not doing the work.

  10. Chikuku

    ChikukuGenius_badge said, 3 months ago

    Melissa, I hope you kill Bin Laden!

  11. Wildcard24365

    Wildcard24365 said, 3 months ago

    Surely one of these possibilities:


    1. Melissa is going back, BD can’t. (As diggit said).
      1.a. BD feels a responsibility to go back, and guilt that he can’t.


    2. He may have formed a particular attachment to Melissa, as she, being so gung ho and in uniform, is a woman he feels he has more in common with, and can relate to (note Boopsie has been voicing more of her own opinions and may be growing apart from BD).
      2.a. Not to mention maybe a bit of a paternal attachment to her, again sort of parallelling his own semi-detachment from his own daughter.


    Altogether, I’d say he is attracted to her vulnerability, as a comrade, protector, as well as a certain sexual attraction.

  12. rhutch436

    rhutch436 said, 3 months ago

    Looks like she’s made a lot of progress and he’s made none…with her…

    (…can’t help it…snicker…”both handed person”…lol…I know, grow up already…snicker…Good one Joe…)

  13. Atma

    Atma said, 3 months ago

    I have a friend that can write with either hand. Left hand writes mirror to the right. And he’s a very successful artist as well.

  14. seablood

    seablood said, 3 months ago

    my guess is that you have to tune in tomorrow to find out what this is about

  15. 4deerinmyyard

    4deerinmyyardGenius_badge said, 3 months ago

    I think Wildcard’s got it: all of the above.

  16. Alabama_Al

    Alabama_Al said, 3 months ago

    When you’re wounded and left on Afghanistan’s plains,
    And the women come out to cut up what remains,
    Just roll to your rifle and blow out your brains
    And go to your God like a soldier.

    Soldier of the Queen!

    THE YOUNG BRITISH SOLDIER (excerpt)
    Rudyard Kipling
    (1892)

    ————————–

    Why not enlist again Melissa? You obviously like the military lifestyle, despite your unfortunate previous experience. Surely the other soldiers have had their consciousness raised in the interim. And if indeed all you do is work on “choppers” in a back support area, the odds are very slight you’ll be called upon to make the “ultimate sacrifice.” It sounds like a patriotic - and altruistic - action on your part.

  17. Just plain Steve

    Just plain Steve said, 3 months ago

    “Choppers” (helicopters) are very much frontline – she may very well be called to make that sacrifice! (But thanks for the Kipling quote – very appropriate.)