Barney & Clyde by Gene Weingarten, Dan Weingarten & David Clark

Barney & ClydeNo Zoom

Comments (9) (Please sign in to comment)

  1. randayn

    randayn GoComics PRO Member said, over 3 years ago

    Take That, Bizarro!

  2. Patchee

    Patchee said, over 3 years ago

    But Michelangelo was gay and the David was modeled after his favorite male prostitute. Since Cynthia loves to push the envelope you would think she would keep the same-sex love story.

  3. fritzoid

    fritzoid GoComics PRO Member said, over 3 years ago

    I can’t tell whether this is intentionally lame or unintentionally lame. But either way, it’s forced and random.

    I hate it when Bizarro does random pun strips, and I hate it when Family Circus does random pun strips (I especially loathe the “Wiley’s Dictionary” gags in B.C., but at least they don’t show up on Sundays.) Since this one, like the Family Circus strips, uses the conceit that it’s being produced by a child, it’s kind of criticism-proof, but if they’re thinking of making this a recurring event I vote “Nay” with extreme prejudice.

  4. ƹʅɗʘ "The whole Haul" Phil D. Albert

    ƹʅɗʘ "The whole Haul" Phil D. Albert said, over 3 years ago

    Let’s go with ‘Kitch’ instead of lame. and random is right-out; this Comic is in-no-small means a Fav because of the topics are consistently Philosophy and Art.

    I won’t touch the ‘forced’ aspect other than to say This is through the eyes of someone else, much younger. But I thought Her Camel/Needle work far superior, yes. That might support the “intentional” Premise.

  5. DirtyDragon

    DirtyDragon said, over 3 years ago

    It’s Dill from “Cul de Sac”!

  6. Night-Gaunt49

    Night-Gaunt49 said, over 3 years ago

    I didn’t know that factoid about Michelangelo myself.

    I rather like it just because its fanciful and sophisticated, for a child, at the same time. But lame, no.

  7. fritzoid

    fritzoid GoComics PRO Member said, over 3 years ago

    “Lame” may have been an overstatement, but I’m still underwhelmed. I’m as much a fan of the Art and Philosophy bent in “Barney and Clyde” as you are, Eldo, but this one doesn’t really mean anything in the context of the strip (whereas Cynthia’s painting of her father as a camel trying to pass through the eye of a needle definitely had a context).

    I can’t help comparing it to the “Calvin & Hobbes” strip where Calvin himself was trapped in a world without artistic perspective, leading to the same pun concerning emotional perspective. There, it gave insight into the character. Here, it’s random and (I still maintain) forced.

    If this has actually been done by a 12 year-old (or however old Cynthia is supposed to be), I’d say “Well done, young lady.” But it wasn’t, anymore than the lame “Billy Steps In” cartoons in *Family Circus” are actually drawn by a child.

    (By the way, one of the Reuben nominees this year is Glenn Keane, the real-life oldest child of Bil Keane. He’s a big shot animator at Disney. I’m still rooting for Richard “Cul de Sac” Thompson, but the man who designed and animated the Beast in Disney’s “Beauty & the Beast” is all right in my book.)

  8. fritzoid

    fritzoid GoComics PRO Member said, over 3 years ago

    Besides (to get really nit-picky), Michaelangelo was primarily a sculptor and, as such, not a particularly good example of one who was a “master of perspective”. Even in his two famous frescoes, the Sistene Chapel ceiling and “The Last Judgment”, the emphasis is almost entirely on the figures (and they’re almost all foreground) so, while foreshortening of the figures themselves is key (and admittedly very well done), there are few backgrounds or architectural structures to render. A better choice might have been Leonardo and “The Last Supper” (although we’d still have the problem of him pining over Francesca rather than Francisco), or Raphael (but while his “School at Athens” would have been a WONDERFUL example to cite, it doesn’t have a high enough recognition factor).

    OK, I’m retiring the Cranky Pants for today. My first post this morning was a spleen-venting about the inherent French inability to ROCK, and that sort of set the tone for subsequent posts…

  9. ƹʅɗʘ "The whole Haul" Phil D. Albert

    ƹʅɗʘ "The whole Haul" Phil D. Albert said, over 3 years ago

    RAD! Never heard of a Master taken to task suchly! I’ll pass on the French Rock nibble, though….

  10. Refresh Comments.